The rule of the people or the rule of marketing?

By: Gašper Blažič

History is the teacher of life, as the old Roman proverb tells us. The irony of that saying, however, is that every present moment becomes history the very next instant. Therefore, it is only afterwards that we can sift through the past and identify those events that can serve as lessons for the future.

Let us take, for example, the current presidency of Donald Trump. He began his term decisively and fulfilled most of his promises during the first quarter of his presidency. However, the veteran businessman was later hindered by his blunt and abrasive character, which came to outweigh the pragmatism needed to implement his programme effectively. While economic reforms in the United States allegedly stalled, the “Slovenian son-in-law,” turned his attention to difficult foreign-policy issues and entered into a partnership with the Kremlin. The consequences became visible in the midterm congressional elections, where Republicans reportedly suffered losses even in Texas, traditionally one of their strongest states. This would be comparable to Democrats losing California.

Of course, this shows that democracy in the United States is still functioning. While even Pope Leo XIV, who is, incidentally, a U.S. citizen, cast a vote, many Republican voters stayed home out of disappointment. Others switched their support to the Democrats. The result reflected this accordingly. It is therefore not surprising that some observers believe Republicans will have to find an entirely new leader before the next presidential election, one from outside the White House.

Democracy in the United States, however, is not the same as democracy in European countries. At least not in some of them. What was once the “rule of the people” has, in many places, become the rule of elites, with the people merely endorsing their decisions. Yet totalitarian regimes also quickly recognised the importance of such “popular endorsement.” For that reason, the Slovenian communist elite began speaking of “democracy” at an early stage, although for a long time it was unwilling to accept a multiparty system. In fact, up until the autumn of 1989, when the Berlin Wall fell, it strongly resisted it. Eventually, however, the concept of a “withdrawal from power” prevailed, sending old-regime figures such as France Popit into early retirement. A good test came in April 1989, when the Socialist Alliance of Working People (SZDL) offered citizens a choice between two candidates for Slovenia’s representative in the Yugoslav federal presidency: either the established Marko Bulc or the lesser-known and relatively young Janez Drnovšek, who had already served in the Yugoslav Assembly and therefore was not an unknown figure. The public chose Drnovšek, which sent a strong signal to the party elite about how it should proceed in the future. This became evident in January 1990 at the final congress of the League of Communists of Yugoslavia (LCY), when it was already known that Slovenia’s first multiparty elections would take place three months later. As the famous quote by Milan Kučan goes: “The people are always right.”

Joseph Schumpeter was evidently right when he rejected the classical definition of democracy as the rule of the people pursuing the common good. Instead, he defined it as an institutional arrangement for making political decisions in which individuals acquire decision-making power through a competitive struggle for voters’ support. In this framework, the issue is no longer how fair that competition is or whether all participants enjoy equal opportunities. In such a contest, it is not the strength of arguments that decides the outcome, but the strength of the loudspeakers. In other words, the argument of power. It is not merely a matter of slogans and demagoguery, but above all of constantly measuring public sentiment and launching stimuli designed to produce desired effects in mass psychology. Public-opinion engineering is therefore what creates the conditions for elections, at which the stronger elite subsequently receives the “official blessing” of legitimacy. It is time for the centre-right elite to fully accept this reality as well; otherwise, the unfinished transition will continue dragging on far into the future like a piece of Chinese chewing gum.

Share

Latest news

Related news